I’ve been playing around with Reels recently, not trying to go viral, just posting consistently and testing what works. Some reels crossed 1,000+ views. Others barely reached 500. I wasn’t doing any strict A/B testing. I just switched up my content based on vibe, trends, and whatever I was feeling that day.
From trending audio to caption length to how many hashtags I used, I started noticing patterns. And that’s what this post is about.
Let’s break it down.
1. Trending Audio/layout = Instant Lift
The reel that used the trending “this was the whole point ❤️” layout on a nighttime NYC skyline pulled 1,388 views — no big transitions, no effects. Just mood + sound.
Takeaway: When trending audio matches the vibe of your content, it works quietly but powerfully. I didn’t follow the full trend, but the music carried the reel.
2. Short Reels (Under 17 Seconds) Do Better
A short reel walking through NYC (with minimal movement) got 2,187 views. Another — me writing “#wearekatz” in the snow — hit 2,078. Both were 10–12 seconds long and cleanly edited.
Takeaway: Short clips = higher completion rate. People swipe fast, and short-form gives your content more chances to loop and be pushed.
3. Simple Captions Outperform Long Explanations
One of my best reels (“A day in my life”) with just a line of text pulled 698 views — more than some visually stronger ones with paragraph-style captions.
Takeaway: Keep it simple. A short caption with clarity or emotion wins attention. Emojis and one-liners seem to perform better than full storytelling.
4. Hashtags Matter Less Than You Think (But Still Help)
I tested reels with 8–10 broad hashtags vs. 3–5 specific ones (like #nyclifestyle or #brooklynbridge). The niche sets worked slightly better — especially on aesthetic clips.
Takeaway: You don’t need to overload. 3–5 relevant hashtags is enough for Instagram to “get” what your content’s about.
5. Cover Thumbnails Still Count
My grid looks better (and got more consistent views) when I used clean stills as covers. Reels with awkward or random frames got skipped, even if the content was good.
Takeaway: People do judge a reel by its cover. Choose your thumbnail with intention — especially if you’re building an aesthetic.
A Look at My Reels: What Performed, What Didn’t
Here’s a visual snapshot of the Reels I’ve been experimenting with — from cozy moments to NYC walks and trend-based edits. These screenshots show what content styles got the most traction (and which didn’t), helping me better understand what my audience engages with.
Reels Screenshot 1
Features lifestyle, travel, and cozy aesthetic reels
Notable high performers:
- Airplane meal tray: 2,640 views
- NYC walking shot: 2,187 views
- Snow writing reel: 2,078 views
Reels Screenshot 2
Includes Ghibli trend, graduation moment, and nighttime cityscapes
Notable high performers:
- NYC skyline with trending “this was the whole point” text: 1,388 views
- Graduation reel: 1,122 views
- Ghibli-inspired animated coffee: 892 views
Reels Screenshot 3
Everyday vlogs, pink outfit reels, ferry views, and NYC street captures
Notable high performers:
- Walking in pink skirt: 1,987 views
- Ferry POV: 1,698 views
- “Recap to Symposium” reel: 1,253 views
So, What Did I Learn?
I didn’t “crack the algorithm.” But I did learn:
- What feels better to create
- What actually earns reach
- And that consistency > virality
Instagram will keep shifting, but if you care about showing up and staying curious — that’s enough. The rest follows.
Final Thoughts
Running these mini A/B tests on my Reels wasn’t about chasing virality, it was about understanding what works for me. I didn’t crack the code (yet), but I’m learning to spot patterns, stay consistent, and create content that feels true to my style.
If you’re experimenting too, remember: sometimes it’s not the fanciest edit or most popular audio that wins — it’s the one that connects.
Got tips or similar trials on your own Reels? I’d love to hear them, drop me a DM or comment!
Mansi's Blog 
Leave a comment